|
|
Bernard Bailyn has recently reinterpreted the early history of the United
States by applying new social research findings on the experiences of European
migrants. In his reinterpretation, migration becomes the organizing principle
for rewriting the history of preindustrial North America. His approach rests on
four separate propositions.
The first of these asserts that residents of early modern England moved
regularly about their countryside; migrating to the New World was simply a
“natural spillover”. Although at first the colonies held little positive
attraction for the English — they would rather have stayed home — by the
eighteenth century people increasingly migrated to America because they regarded
it as the land of opportunity. Secondly, Bailyn holds that, contrary to the
notion that used to flourish in America history textbooks, there was never a
typical New World community. For example, the economic and demographic character
of early New England towns varied considerably.
Bailyn’s third proposition suggest two general patterns prevailing among
the many thousands of migrants: one group came as indentured servants, another
came to acquire land. Surprisingly, Bailyn suggests that those who recruited
indentured servants were the driving forces of transatlantic migration. These
colonial entrepreneurs helped determine the social character of people who came
to preindustrial North America. At first, thousands of unskilled laborers were
recruited; by the 1730’s, however, American employers demanded skilled
artisans.
Finally, Bailyn argues that the colonies were a half-civilized hinterland
of the European culture system. He is undoubtedly correct to insist that the
colonies were part of an Anglo-American empire. But to divide the empire into
English core and colonial periphery, as Bailyn does, devalues the achievements
of colonial culture. It is true, as Bailyn claims, that high culture in the
colonies never matched that in England. But what of seventeenth-century New
England, where the settlers created effective laws, built a distinguished
university, and published books? Bailyn might respond that New England was
exceptional. However, the ideas and institutions developed by New England
Puritans had powerful effects on North American culture.
|
|